V For Vendetta

[image:115:l] It’s such a rare thing to go to the movies and see something that challenges you to think or act. Few movies are about ideas as much as they are about actors, images, and technology. Still fewer are those movies that can combine good acting startling images, fx, and ideas. When that happens it tends to make for a movie that gets under my skin and becomes a favorite of mine. I’m happy to report that it’s happened again with V For Vandetta.

I’m not familiar with the 80′s comic by Alan Moore that this is based on, nor do I know Moore’s reasons for taking his name off the movies credits and disassociating himself from it. Obviously the original was not an allegory for the Bush administration while this certainly has Patriot Act era undertones. Taking place in the 2020′s we even see old news footage of anti-Bush demonstrations that are protesting events including Iraq that are alluded to as being part of the chain of events leading to the authoritarian Britain of the film’s present. Exposing and avenging a long running government conspiracy is at the root of the actions of the masked lead nicknamed V and played by a Hugo Weaving. We never see Weaving who is not so much a hero but the welcome villain the governemnt has created and that they and the people deserve. It’s a bit annoying to try and listen to a man speak who’s mouth I can’t see move, but on some level it works as a symbol of V’s status as the voice of the oppressed speaking from a collective muffled silence so that all may speak freely again. Fortunately for this theory it is backed up by later imagery of the film in which V’s role as everyman and his plan for the anniversary of the Gunpowder Plot of 4 centuries ago, come together. I found the visuals of the movies culminating actions epic and exillarating for both the cinematic scope of them and their kinship to the themes that they gave visual representation for.

[image:117:l]

There’s alot of dialogue to sift through and wax philosophic about in V and I’m not sure I agree with all of it; but it’s certainly all interesting and worthy of debate. V believes for instance that the people should not be afraid of their government but rather governments should be afraid of the people. While being an inspiring line that appeals to the anarchist in me I’m not sure I want to live in a world where average citizens run amok causing chaos when they’re not happy. Of course if the choice is one or the other I might waiver and I certainly want politicians fearing for their jobs. Preferably they’d lose them through voting rather than beheading though. Otherwise were in Robespeirre country and watching revolutions eat their young.

But much of what V stands for, says, and does is operating on that higher level of genius that is beyond simple black and white colorations. While he kills alot of innocent people he is admittedly a product of system, a sort of Frankenstein’s monster turning on it’s creator with all that creatures ill-fashioned clumsiness and lack of subtlety. And yet he is still charming, brilliant, heroic, and human. Natalie Portman becomes his connection to humanity and the relationship between the two is genuinely interesting and meaningful. At his core V may just be a vulnerable and rejected man just looking for a little acceptance and connection. Just feeling as if he’s understood by someone he respects and gets him makes a world of difference in the end.

The whole segment that leads to Portman shaving her hair is interesting in and of itself. I can’t mention much about it here due to its spoiler potential, but I will say that it connected with something I’d been thinking about alot lately regarding froth coming through hardship, and becoming free by losing one’s self and ego. [image:116:l]

I really liked the movie and don’t discount my bias towards its political message as being part of the reason. It’s probably not a non-partisan movie or one that conservatives would find as truly disturbing and incendiary as I did. At least not in a good way. The mask V hides behind is intended to look like the Gunpowder Plot mastermind Guy Fawkes and after the movie I wanted to don me a John Hinckley mask and take to the streets in the name of the ever decreasing abstractions freedom, justice, and liberty. This is probably one of the reasons many will dislike this film and I certainly don’t advocate a bloodspree. But in a country where the media is owned by corporations that own the politicians, a country where 1% control 90% of the wealth, and one in which the President makes laws and breaks them at will with no ramifications we might soon be at the point where we have nothing to lose but our chains.

3 Responses to “V For Vendetta”


  • Let me open with this. Any film the Dude tells me to see is a film that is automaticaly worth going to see, only because i trust him that much with my psyche, as well as my movie watching dollar.

    However, it looks like more of the raging, flamable, social garbage comentary, that has passed as a good movie going experience. Infact, even the trailer hits with force like a ton of bricks but passes by like a weaping willow, forgotten out of lack of consequence.

    I strugle to see the substance in a movie about revolution against tyranny, that has been made so many times. The V series, Cromwell, any film about the three musketiers, even the Star Wars films, Metropolis, any Schwartzeneger film before ’89, the Patriot, Robin Hood Prince of Thieves, all have some ‘down with the man’ fight for freedom. The premis itself can be watered down to resemble Carpenter’s Escape from L.A. An anti hero/villain battles the corupt theocricy that made him, for freedom.

    That is not to say any of my words make the movie bad, but you see how it is unlikely that this one of many is suposed to flush the cinematic cesspool of yore.

    Also, Johnathan Livingston Seagull had story, symbolism, and imagry, but it agreeably would never translate to film. It is a singular story about bettering yourself that can be appreciated on many levels, but it would be a snooser on celluloid.

    I guess at first glance, it should be “ABC, for Already Been Chewed”, or “B for Been Done”, or “V for Vapid”, ( i stole that from the TV.) I trust you Dude, and will see this film, but i hope it is not your B for Bush hatred that is fueling your fondness for this film. I am Passionate about my hatred for Larry the Cable guy, but nothing will make me see the Health Inspector.

  • Well said B for B-dog.

    As I indicated in my R for review it is quite possible that my politics E for enhanced the movie going experience here. The movies own politics are not overly subtle but I think those who have insinuated that it makes a hero out of this L for left wing icon are not quite getting it.

    There is some A for ambivilence in Vendetta. Perhaps its moral outlook is a bit black and white but then its based on a comic book and geared towards a receptive audience. I was receptive not only because of my political outlook but due as well to my natural predilections to themes of revolution, freedom, redemption, and sacrifice. Most films have a distinct point of view. The main thing is that they speak the language of that viewpoint fluently X for executing it with a blending of the visual, literary, acting to make a coherent statement.

    Vendetta pretty much does this. Sure it’s flawed, it’s too verbose at times for one thing. But even its verbosity is interesting. As for its political viewpoint, well it’s as in your face as any comic book. I can actually see alot in common between V and Batman. V is Batman on E for emotional steroids.

    I appreciate your confidence in my opinion. Am I sure you’ll like it? No. Would I prefer you give me the $20 or so you’ll spend for you and Megan to see this? Of course. Is this one of the best movies I’ve ever seen? No. Do I want to see it again? D for Definitely. Is it more interesting and provacative than most of what’s out there now or in recent weeks? I certainly think so. So take the advice of my capped and highlighted letters and enjoy.

  • How do you get more provacative than Mrs. Henderson presents. Come on. My brother loved it as well, but i am still, as you put it, not getting it.

Leave a Reply